Their relationship became a focus of public interest when MTV chronicled their journey to marriage in the reality TV series "Bam's Unholy Union," which aired in 2007. The show documented their relationship from the engagement phase through their wedding, significantly raising Rothstein’s public profile.

Marriage and Public Scrutiny

Missy and Bam Margera were married in February 2007. The couple's relationship frequently drew media attention due to speculation about their marital struggles. As early as 2010, rumors circulated claiming that the couple was living apart. Margera stated in interviews that they resided in different cities but were still married, reportedly meeting once a week.

There were additional allegations that Margera had been unfaithful, and he publicly acknowledged having female friends in San Francisco and West Chester, asserting that Rothstein was aware of these relationships. Despite the controversy, there were no early confirmations from either party about a formal separation.

Divorce and Misleading Rumors

In 2012, false reports surfaced online suggesting that Bam and Missy had finalized their divorce, including a widely shared post from what was later discovered to be a fake Twitter account. A mutual friend of the couple initially dismissed the rumor, but neither Rothstein nor Margera publicly addressed the matter at the time.

Subsequent stories claimed Missy hosted a party to celebrate their separation, though these reports remained unverified. Although some accounts suggested that the couple had been attending counseling as early as two years into their marriage, these efforts reportedly did not resolve their issues.