Reasons Behind Marital Breakdowns

Each of Collins’ three marriages dissolved for different reasons. His first marriage ended partly due to the demanding nature of his music career, which kept him away from home for long periods. Andrea reportedly moved away with the children to be closer to her family. Rumors circulated that she had an affair with someone who had been employed as a decorator by Collins.

The breakdown of his marriage to Jill Tavelman was attributed in part to familial tensions, including issues with her mother. It was widely reported—though denied by Collins—that he initiated the separation via fax, a claim he has refuted in subsequent interviews.

His third marriage to Orianne Cevey ended more amicably, with both parties citing diverging personal interests rather than conflict. Orianne acknowledged that the relationship had simply run its course. She expressed surprise when news surfaced that Collins had begun dating Dana shortly after their separation, although she stated that she harbored no wish to reconcile romantically.

Media Perspective and Public Statements

In various interviews, Collins has offered candid reflections on his relationships and declared his desire to avoid repeating past emotional and financial ordeals. While expressing affection for Dana Tyler, he consistently clarifies that he is not seeking marriage. He has often referenced his previous financial losses from divorce as part of the reason for remaining unwed, humorously remarking that preserving his remaining savings is a priority.