Raised in a Roman Catholic household, both of her parents later converted to Judaism. Leggero herself identifies as Jewish today, though she has expressed that she is not particularly religious. From a young age, she demonstrated a passion for performance and the stage, known for her ability to imitate celebrities and various characters. Despite concerns from her family that an acting career might not be financially sustainable, Leggero pursued her passion and later achieved notable success in the entertainment industry, accruing a net worth of approximately $2.5 million.

Education

Natasha Leggero attended elementary school in Chicago, Illinois, followed by Rockford East High School in her hometown. An outstanding student, she actively participated in drama classes and was noted for her talent and enthusiasm for performance.

After graduating from high school, Leggero moved to New York City where she enrolled in both the Stella Adler Conservatory and Hunter College. At the Stella Adler Conservatory, a highly respected institution for dramatic arts, she studied theater. Simultaneously, she pursued a degree in psychology at Hunter College. Following her academic pursuits, she lived briefly in Los Angeles before spending some time in Sydney, Australia. Her combined education in psychology and drama laid a strong foundation for her future in comedy and acting.