The insecurity of Faith in the relationship with her husband is the main reason according to the rumors. Faith started to see all the female friends of Tim as his secret girlfriends. There were also rumors that Faith is trying to save the relationship and Tim is fooling around with all the women he could get. Tim’s road tour with Cassadee Pope created a lot of friction between the couple  and Faith’s brother came to mediate things between them.

There were reports that Faith openly accused that Tim is cheating on her with the masseuse, Taylor Swift. On the other hand, Tim thought that he and his wife should be together to keep up their brand name. This comment angered Faith as Tim wanted to maintain the relationship just for the sake of the brand name.

All the rumors were shattered when the couple appeared on stage in 2014 and kissed. Tim said that it is true that Faith tried to control him and isolated him from all his friends. However, he also said that made him what he is today and he said that he is grateful to Faith.

From the beginning, Faith denied all the rumors about the separation, yet, the rumors kept popping in. Faith is not accused of any extramarital affairs or boyfriends. There are no details about her previous love life before she met Tim. Though Tim is associated with a lot of sex rumors, including bisexual rumors, their relationship seemed to be strong.

Another big rumor of separation hit the media when Tim announced that he has a secret son. It turned out that he is not the biological father. He was in close relationship with Kristine Donahue, who then parted away. Later, Kristine had a son due to her relationship with someone else. Tim proposed Kristine to marry him so that he would take care of him. She agreed and things changed when he went on a tour with Faith Hill and proposed her. Though he did not marry Kristine, he had a close relationship with her and also helped her raise her son.

When Faith came to know that he is still in a relationship with Kristine, she was very furious, according to the sources. It was said that Tim cut all his strings for Taylor, though Hill was requesting him to do the same for years. When asked about this rumor, the couple denied it completely and said that the rumor is full of misrepresentations and inaccurate data. But, He agrees that he sees Kristine’s son as his own.