Shaw, then started dating her future husband, Jason King. They were friends since she was in the band. They started to date in 2005 and started to live together with Shaw’s son. In 2008, they announced their engagement and got married in 2009. Their marriage came to an end in 2012, when the couple announced that they have separated. In 2014, two years after her divorce, she announced that she is dating Sam Greenfield. He has already moved in with her. This was her first serious relationship after she got separated from Jason. Even though they announced their separation in February, they split during Christmas. Even after separation, Jason used to visit Shaw and her son for Pyjama Sundays when, they used to be in Pyjama and watch movies like Jungle Book.

After their separation, there were rumors that Day and Shaw are planning to get back together. But, Shaw immediately denied that Day is now with Stephanie and have a son together. She also media as a small reason for her split from Jason. Jason is a shy and private person. With media surrounding her neck and of those who are near her, Jason felt very uncomfortable

When asked about her separation, she blamed her hectic career for it. They both were not able to spend considerable time with each other and ended growing apart from each other. Her separation from Day can be blamed on drugs, booze and Day being a womanizer. In an interview, Day said that he regrets all his mistakes. When they split up, no one blamed her as they were very aware of his long list of affairs. All the rumors were targeted on Day stated that he might have cheated on her or found his next woman. She was happy that her fiancé, Terry is not bothered by her history. There were no concrete reasons as why her engagement with Terry broke. She never talked a lot about Terry and Terry also remained a silent tune for the questions about Shaw.

Though Day left her when she needed him, the most, she has a good relationship with him. He also had a good relationship with his wife. They manage to maintain this scenario for the sake of their son, Corey. With a heart-breaking love life and a failed relationship with Jason, Shaw does not want to immediately choose her next lover. She wanted to take time to find the person who would suit her needs. There are no romantic or sex affairs that revolve around Shaw.